Showing posts with label Arvind Kejriwal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arvind Kejriwal. Show all posts

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Broken Windows

I am presently reading a book by Malcolm Gladwell, called "Tipping Point". In this book, the author has presented an idea called "Broken Windows". I am repeating a paragraph from this book, since the explanation there is as good as my own understanding of the concept.


"Broken Windows was the brainchild of the criminologists James Q. Wilson and George Kelling. Wilson and Kelling argued that crime is the inevitable result of disorder. If a window is broken and left un-repaired, people walking by will conclude that no one cares and no one is in charge. Soon, more windows will be broken and the sense of anarchy will spread from the building to the street on which it faces, sending a signal thatanything goes"



The author further goes on to explain how administrators in the city of New York went on to reduce crime levels in the city, not by cracking down on big crime, but by cracking down on the petty,'in-your-face' crimes. In short, they got about mending their "BrokenWindows". This makes me think, how does it apply to us?



India today is plagued by extreme corruption. Everyone from the politicians, the police forces, armed forces, judiciary as well as topbusiness leaders seems to be corrupt. Every news channel is racing tobe the first to expose the corrupt. The monster of corruption seems too large and unstoppable. Honest and dedicated citizens like Shri Anna Hazare and Shri Arvind Kejriwal are trying to fight the monsterand bring in accountability. But they are confronted by the establishment which is both powerful and wily. They are methodicallytrying to break down their efforts. The investigation agencies and the judiciary are trying to bring the corrupt politicians to book. But today the corrupt leaders seem to outnumber the honest investigators.



But where did all this start? We were not programmed like this from birth. I think it all started with the small bribes which became apart of our everyday lives. Many of us are guilty of paying a 'Tip' to the Ticket Collector to get priority on a waiting list in a train.Many don't give a second thought, and infact take pride in 'Tipping' atraffic cop to avoid paying higher fines for traffic offenses. Thisbehaviour has slowly made corruption acceptable in our society. No big criminal is born a big criminal. It always starts with petty crimesand thefts which go unpunished, which embolden a person to graduate to bigger crimes. Similarly, as a society, our acceptance, and often our indulgence in petty corruption has led to this monster of corruption which is now sitting on our head.



Our tolerance to corruption is further evident from the fact that we do not mind re-electing politicians guilty of corruption. When the news of a corruption story breaks, all of us get up and say "Now this has crossed all limits and crossed all boundaries". But then donothing about it. If we want to stop this monster, then prosecution of the guilty alone will not help.



We need to accept that we have "Broken Windows" of our moral character as a society.



Just as the decay started with petty bribes, the repair too will have to start at the very grassroots.



History teaches us that Gandhiji's non-cooperation movement made the British Rulers see stars. It was not a big fight or war which drove the British out. It was a simple and small act of non-cooperation at very low levels but spread across the country that made administration impossible. To support the battle of Shri Anna Hazare, we need asimilar non-corruption movement in our everyday behavior. We need small battles and small victories over our own moral character first.The big corruption cases today are not the diagnosis of the malaise but purely it's symptoms. The diagnosis is the deterioration of our own moral character. Once we accept the need for change and cleansing at this level, the rest will automatically begin to fall in place. The results will not be immediate, but they will be stronger and long lasting.

We really need to repair and mend our "Broken Windows" first.